Best Mystery Podcasts

Updated May 1, 2024

Multiple streamers have reported on Best Mystery Podcasts. We put together 25 of the top ones.

Weird Darkness: Stories of the Paranormal, Supernatural, Legends, Lore, Mysterious, Macabre, Unsolved

Weird Darkness is a podcast hosted by Darren Marlar, a horror enthusiast. Throughout the podcast, Marlar discusses a variety of topics related to the paranormal, supernatural, legends, lore, mysterious, macabre, and unsolved. Episodes usually feature interviews with experts on the topics discussed, as well as real-life stories from people who have experienced something strange or inexplicable. The podcast also includes unique music, sound effects, and commentary from Marlar himself. Weird Darkness aims to provide listeners with a source of entertainment and education about the paranormal and all things dark and mysterious.

CBS Radio Mystery Theater

The CBS Radio Mystery Theater was a weekly old-time radio show broadcast on CBS Radio Network from 1974 to 1982. Hosted by actor and screenwriter E.G. Marshall, the series featured classic horror and suspense stories, often with a supernatural element, and featured an array of guest stars including Vincent Price, Peter Cushing, and Orson Welles. Each episode began with the show's signature introduction, "The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents..." followed by a brief description of the episode. The series was a hit with audiences of all ages and was highly acclaimed for its suspenseful storylines and excellent production values. The show is still fondly remembered by fans of old-time radio.

Unexplained Mysteries

Unexplained Mysteries is a podcast from Parcast that explores strange and mysterious events that remain unsolved. Each episode dives deep into one of these unsolved mysteries, examining the facts and theories surrounding the event. From the vanished crew of the Mary Celeste to the mysterious death of Elisa Lam, the podcast takes an in-depth look at some of the world’s most mysterious cases. Hosts Richard and Molly examine the evidence, offer possible explanations, and discuss the impact the unsolved mysteries have had on culture and conspiracy.

Darkest Mysteries from Reddit 2022 - Best Reddit Stories Podcast 2022

This podcast episode features some of the best Reddit stories from the Reddit subreddit r/DarkestMysteries. From a mysterious abandoned house to a woman freezing to death in her car, these are some of the creepiest and most mysterious stories Reddit has to offer. The stories range from strange and spooky to downright bizarre, leaving listeners mystified and enthralled at the same time. Hosts Cody and Priscilla discuss their favorite Reddit stories and share their own thoughts and theories about each one.

Paranormal Mysteries Podcast

Paranormal Mysteries Podcast is a show about supernatural and unexplained stories from around the world. Hosted by paranormal investigator J. Nathan Couch, each episode delves into strange and mysterious cases of the unexplained, from hauntings and UFO sightings to cryptids and other bizarre phenomena. Through interviews with experts and eye-witness accounts, Couch examines the evidence and attempts to uncover the truth behind these supernatural mysteries. From legendary tales to modern-day encounters, Paranormal Mysteries Podcast takes listeners on a journey through the unknown.