Comedy True Crime Podcasts

Updated May 1, 2024

Many streamers have explored Comedy True Crime Podcasts. We put together 25 of the top ones.

Wine & Crime

Wine & Crime is a true crime and comedy podcast hosted by three best friends. On each episode, they banter about unsolved murders and mysteries while sipping wine. They also discuss current events, pop culture, and conspiracy theories. Each episode is a lighthearted take on true crime, and their lively conversations are sure to keep listeners both informed and entertained.

Let Them Fight: A Comedy History Podcast

Let Them Fight is a comedy history podcast that takes a deep dive into the world of professional wrestling. Hosts Jacob Trimmer and Tim Groeschel explore the rich history of wrestling, as well as the personalities and storylines that made it so entertaining. From the golden age of wrestling in the 80s and 90s to the cutting edge of today's WWE, they take an irreverent and often hilarious look at the business and its legends. With a mix of interviews, research, and analysis, they examine why professional wrestling still captivates us today.

True Crime Obsessed

True Crime Obsessed is a comedic true crime podcast hosted by Patrick Hinds and Gillian Pensavalle. The pair present a humorous and entertaining look into some of the most notorious cases in history. Each episode dives into the story of a different crime, from the perspective of two true crime-obsessed hosts. They provide a mix of news, interviews, theories, and humor, while also allowing listeners the chance to get to know the victims of these heinous crimes. They also have a segment called “True Crime Obsessed Recommends” where they recommend movies, books, and podcasts related to the topic of the episode, giving their audience the opportunity to explore further.

Crime in Sports

This podcast covers a variety of crimes committed by athletes across different sports. The hosts, James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman, discuss two major cases: the NFL’s Aaron Hernandez and the NCAA’s Jerry Sandusky. They analyze the different factors that led to these athletes committing their crimes and how they were each sentenced. They also compare the punishments given to athletes who have committed crimes to those handed out to non-athletes. The hosts conclude that athletes often receive preferential treatment when it comes to sentencing. They also discuss the lack of accountability within the sports world and how it contributes to the problem of athletes getting away with criminal offenses.

Bumblebutt Podcast X: True Crime / Paranormal

In this podcast, Adam and Herschel dive into the world of true crime and paranormal stories. They discuss famous and lesser-known cases, share their own personal experiences, and explore theories and evidence related to various mysteries. They also talk to experts and eyewitnesses to get their take on the events. Towards the end of the podcast, they provide their own analysis and reflections on the stories they’ve discussed.

Just The Tip-Sters: True Crime Podcast

Just The Tip-Sters is a true crime podcast hosted by Melissa Morgan and Sarah Yost. Each episode explores different unsolved mysteries and strange events from around the world. They provide an in-depth look at each case, including interviews with family and friends of the victims and law enforcement officers. In addition to discussing each case, the podcast also provides tips on how to stay safe and avoid becoming a victim. Just The Tip-Sters is a must-listen for any true crime enthusiast.

I Said God Damn! A True Crime Podcast

"I Said God Damn! A True Crime Podcast" is an audio exploration of true crime stories. Hosted by journalist and podcast creator, Elise Eberwein, the podcast delves into cases that have been forgotten, overlooked, or simply not given enough attention. Through interviews with experts and family members of victims, Elise attempts to shine a light on the stories behind these cases and the impact they had on the people involved. Each episode is dedicated to a different case, with topics ranging from kidnappings to mass shootings, and from serial killers to unsolved mysteries. Along the way, Elise also looks at the wider context of our criminal justice system and the larger societal issues at play.

Housewives of True Crime

Housewives of True Crime is a podcast hosted by Gretchen Macaulay and Tabitha Kane, two true crime enthusiasts. In each episode, they discuss different stories of crime and justice, looking at the cases from different angles and focusing on the women involved. They cover everything from serial killers to cold cases, and even their own personal stories of crime. Along the way, they bring in expert guests to help them explore the cases and provide a better understanding of the victims, the perpetrators, and the legal system. The podcast has a humorous tone and contains plenty of sarcasm and snark.